There is not a single mention of a certain political era in Catherine Opie’s To Be Seen, the esteemed photographer’s first major museum exhibition in Britain, presenting pivotal works going back to the 1990s. Both epic and intimate, the images capture the American terrain and the American family. Above all, they are concerned with the 64-year-old’s career-long preoccupation in the portrayal of gay, lesbian and queer Americans absent from mainstream art history. The majority of the photos were created well before recent political administrations and yet, browsing the show, it comes across as a potent challenge to the current climate – to such a degree that it evokes a feeling of near cathartic relief.
A Mission of Bravery
For nearly three decades, Opie taught photography at a major university in Los Angeles, and would instruct her students that it was part of the calling of the serious artist to show “a model in a public space of what it is to be courageous”. So it is with To Be Seen, which includes some of Opie’s most well-known and most courageous works, from her images of friends to denizens of LA’s 1990s leather dyke scene: the legendary, gender-fluid Pig Pen, a friend who appears in a collection of shots, gazing calmly at the camera, defying the viewer to define them; her Being and Having series, an pioneering interrogation to gender norms depicting 13 masculine-presenting lesbians posing in fake facial hair, in an absurdist performance of masculinity; and Dyke, in which Opie’s friend Steakhouse – in terms of brave – poses with her back to the camera, the word “dyke” inscribed in large elaborate script across the back of her neck.
“Folks would say: ‘Cathy, are you trying to empty the world of everybody but queers?’”
In 1993, Opie created what has become, to her annoyance, her most widely known photograph, Self Portrait/Cutting, in which she, too, sits with her back to the camera, here with the bloody silhouette of a child’s drawing of a house and family incised into her skin.
Moving the Viewer
But we’ll discuss that later. First, here’s Opie via Zoom from her studio. She’s swamped, about to swing through London for the exhibition’s run. Opie is energized with pre-show energy and what appears to be the basic defiance necessary of a certain kind of artist working in the US right now, but it’s possible she is constantly like this: wry, vivacious, as spirit-lifting as her photos. She is eager to talk about creating an “iconic” image, but her true aim is “to make a photo affect you in your body”.
Opie’s works indeed hit the viewer at a primal level. In Divinity Fudge, the eponymous performance artist and drag act looks frankly at the camera, wearing her best. In Self-Portrait/Nursing, we see Opie nursing her infant son Oliver in a traditional, art history pose, but with key differences: she is short-haired and tattooed, her naked skin marked with scars from her previous artwork, Self-Portrait/Pervert.
What’s moving about these images is how, tonally, they oppose the bigot’s idea of the “extreme lifestyle”. Opie, of course, isn’t trying to be radical, but rather seeks to record her life and the lives of her peers with a openness that refuses to become rigid in the face of opposition. “Sincerity” is the word she uses for this: “Sincerity is really important to me. I think those basic qualities are in fact very Christian. Meanwhile, organized religion has left me out of the mix because of my orientation.”
Essentially these photos proclaim the moral right to exist so that “paradoxically,” she says, “I sometimes have what people think of as big spiritual ideas.”
The Spark of Recognition
This sense of being moved by photography first hit her at the age of 11 when she saw a photograph in a textbook of a girl working in a cotton mill. It was taken in 1908 by Lewis Hine and one thought instantly struck her: the child could’ve been her. Opie’s father owned a factory in Ohio, and the image provoked a profound moment of identification. The factory made craft materials for hobbyists. So, says Opie, “Although I came out of this family that didn’t want me to be an artist, particularly my businessman father, I was immersed in creativity.”
Although the family moved to California when Opie was 13, she held onto a deep interest in the romance of the American heartland – which, as she grew older, intersected with an interest in what it meant to be relegated to its margins. There is a photo in the exhibition of Opie at nine years old – Self-Portrait 1970 – with a bowl haircut and big black glasses, throwing a strongman pose. Not a straight child. Was her non-conformity a problem?
“It was hard for my mom. Although what’s weird is I ended up being my mom. She always had a short haircut. She wore no makeup. She was a PE teacher. She wanted me in dresses and bows, but she was a Bermuda-shorts-wearing jock, the best at every single sport she did.” Opie throws back her head and laughs. “All my friends are like, ‘Lou’s a lesbian, right?’ And I’m like, ‘Lou’s not a lesbian.’”
A Mother’s Perspective
The funny thing is, says Opie, the experience of having Oliver compelled her to confront her own assumptions, too. As part of a series from the mid-2000s, Oliver is photographed as a toddler in a pink tutu. She smiles. “Because, from my masculine identity, I had wanted him to be a stereotypically masculine boy. I didn’t want a girl because I didn’t know how I would talk to her about being a girl. And with my son, here I was grappling with wanting him to toss a football with me in the back yard because that’s what I had always envisioned – and he just wanted to play with dolls and the doll house. He was not at all a masculine boy. He was the tutu-wearing boy. And now he’s publicly identified and he’s remains the pink-tutu boy.”
Beyond Queer Portraiture
In the late 2000s, Opie crisscrossed the US creating portraits of school football players, an interest she developed after visiting relatives in Louisiana. Similar to other cultural examinations of male adolescence through sports, Opie started attending practices, intrigued by their symbolic weight. “I was really moved by them. And I realised this was an extension of America’s visual identity.”
The question she asked herself was: “How do I extend an American landscape through a body of work?” But she was also trying to broaden her range to answer another question. “People were asking me, ‘Cathy, you only make portraits of LGBTQ+ people. Are you trying to clear out the world of everybody but LGBTQ+ individuals?’”
A query straight artists focusing on mainstream subjects have ever been asked. “No. Right. These are the questions I get. I eagerly await the day when every single heterosexual child has to announce their orientation to their parents as heterosexual.” Still, Opie says, she wanted to diversify what had been a largely LGBTQ+-centric body of work, which grew out of her experiences at art school in San Francisco in the 1980s. “A very specific time. We’re talking high theory in the classroom. We’re talking highly theoretical training that was trying to contextualize art in this new way.”
A Practical Artist
Art school theory has its shortcomings and Opie has never been interested in isolating herself within the academy’s high walls. She’s a commercial beast: as well as her career as a teacher, she has always worked commercially. She shot a prestigious fashion brand’s campaign and, earlier in her career, she says, “I was doing weddings, editorial shoots. I was shooting for magazines. I was picking up as many editorial jobs along the way as possible. I had all the equipment. I knew how to use drones, all of that.”
On the surface, this commercial work was a way of making money to fund her fine art. But honestly, says Opie, “I loved it. I loved making my skill set as large as it could be. I’m super into being skilled. I’m hardcore Aries. I believe in being capable.” One can imagine her in cargo shorts, tools dangling off her belt loops. “I know. I don’t have the photographer’s vest. But there’s a LOT in the cargo shorts’ pockets.”
Something about this combination has made Opie very cool in fashion circles. A famous singer is said to love her work. This is a surprise to Opie but, she says, upon reflection, she’d welcome that support for her series examining how the church asserts its authority through architecture.
Art That Challenges
If commercial work was one way for Opie to avoid getting bogged down in theory, another was to pivot to the physical. Self-Portrait/Cutting (1993) was made in response to the relationship between queer domestic life and a homophobic world, at a time when any depictions of the LGBTQ+ household were considered subversive and radical.
When her friend carefully carved a child’s drawing of an stereotypical family and house into Opie’s back, the photographer hadn’t yet had kids. What frustrates her now is the fact that it is still misunderstood: she will have to assert and reassert that her aim was not simply to shock. For the exhibition, she says, the audio tour includes a moment where she advises parents on